For Good Grief(ing), Silence is Golden

By Donna Lee Schillinger

Like one who takes away a garment on a cold day, or like vinegar poured on soda, is one who sings songs to a heavy heart. Proverbs 25:20

In honor of my grandfather, Wilbur Hunter, who passed away on May 8, 2010, I offer this observation: Americans suck at comforting people. There are some wonderful things about American culture, but when it comes to grieving, our culture has left us completely unprepared. We have no idea how to comfort someone who has just lost someone very close. Probably because we just don’t think it’s ever going to happen to us!

When my brother-in-law passed away at 46 years of age, his wife needed support that I didn’t know how to give. Having been married for almost 15 years, this man was her life. When I saw her for the first time after he passed away, she looked like I’d never seen her look before – lost. It was so sad and she was so upset and I… was clueless as to how to help. I was hurting acutely as well, and having recently suffered the loss of my own son, one would think I would know what to do in such a situation. In those first hours at my sister-in-law’s home, I wracked my brain for some direction on how to behave. I knew what my sister-in-law was feeling, but also knew better than to tell her that. That’s rule number one, a grieving person doesn’t want to hear that you know how they feel – she won’t believe it or appreciate it, even if it’s true.

Then the book of Job came to mind. Now Job’s three friends have gone down in history as examples of what not to do for a friend who is suffering, but that’s not fair. It’s true that those guys screwed up the moment they opened their mouths, but do you recall what they did before they spoke? Take note: “When they saw [Job] from a distance, they could hardly recognize him, they began to weep aloud, and they tore their robes and sprinkled dust on their heads. Then they sat on the ground with him for seven days and seven nights. No one said a word to him, because they saw how great his suffering was” (Job 2:12-13).

Here it is – how to co-grieve in two simple steps: 1. Don’t hold back your own feelings of grief. 2. Just sit quietly with the grieving person. Simple. On the flipside, our proverb tells us what not to do: sing songs. Duh! Right? Wrong. Maybe your momma taught you better than to break out into song while you’re in the presence of someone who is grieving, but I can tell you from experience, not all have the good judgment not to “sing songs.”

A life has been lost, but all we can muster is 15 minutes of reverence. About that soon after the mourners arrive, they start discussing the weather, the traffic, a movie that just came out – anything. It’s like, “We did our thing, we gave a tearful hug to the widow, life goes on, get over it.” For the person mourning, the fact that life goes on is infuriating. The person mourning most heavily would like all the world to stop for at least one full day and observe her grief with her – to sit in silent contemplation of the one she has lost.

On the day of my son’s funeral, we went to my mother’s house after the burial and within 10 minutes, it was like we were at a family reunion. All the reverence for the occasion that had been apparent at the grave site dissipated and only my husband and I were left sitting on the couch, choking down a sandwich, listening to mundane conversation around us, wondering what the heck just happened! Did everyone simultaneously forget that our son died?

It doesn’t always play out this way. Sometimes the person who was closest to the deceased will not appear to be heavily grieved, and some may not want comfort. Some, particularly if the death of their loved one was a result of a long battle with disease or from old age, may have done a lot of their heavy grieving in the months that preceded the death. They may be in a “let’s celebrate their life” mode. In that case, do it, celebrate their life. This doesn’t mean it’s OK to start talking about books and movies within 15 minutes, it means the grieving person wants the mood to be positive, but still all about the one they love.

The important thing is to take your cues from the person with whom you’re grieving; match their mood and don’t change the subject. This day is all about the person who passed away. Stay focused. That’s it. It’s simple, yet it does not necessarily feel natural or comfortable. Do you think Job’s friends might have been getting a little hungry for a sub sandwich or antsy for pillow or something around about day four of sitting on the ground with Job? We may feel extremely uncomfortable from the minute we arrive to the minute we walk out the door – but we can know that we’re doing the right thing and the only thing we can do for a grieving person.

Hold this thought: Shared silence is comforting.

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine

2 thoughts on “For Good Grief(ing), Silence is Golden

  1. Hey!
    Thank you for this article. Over the last few months I have been grieving for my grandpa who is still alive yet is slowly dying. It is true. Silence is the most comforting thing and someone who doesn’t need to talk but will sit with me.

    Another tremendous blessing was a lady who told me it was alright to grieve. I think everyone thinks it’s something you’ll just snap out of and be happy again. But she told me it was alright to mourn and weep. Jesus wept and on the night of His death it would not have been appropriate for the disciples to be joyful.

    Thanks again,
    In His love,

    1. Thanks, Anne, for your input. You are correct and let’s not also forget Jesus said “blessed are those who mourn.” There’s a lot of ways to interpret that, but one thing it says to me is that it is an admirable quality to feel so deeply. Mourning is evidence that a person has had a real and deep connection to another person. Why in the world would we wish that away?

      Donna Lee Schillinger
      i believe in miracles, do you? Read my blog at

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s